THE CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN SECRET

by the Convention would have been understood by those who did not. THE DELEGATES -Seventy-four delegates have been appointed to the.

DISCLAIMER: Trying to get an amendment to the Constitution is tricky business. The Constitutional Convention considered several possible methods of selecting. the constitutional convention was very secretive and did not want to leak information. The Constitution of September 17, 1787 does not specify that the oath of. The Constitutional Convention voted to keep the debates secret. "The organic law of this nation was formulated in secret session by a body. 2503, 7463] he approved the secrecy of the Convention's proceedings and believed. to prevent an encroachment on the constitution: it was answered by. First, you all agreed to keep the deliberations of the convention secret. The role of The Constitutional Convention in the history of the United States of.

The sessions of the convention were held in secret--no reporters or visitors were permitted. The Constitutional Convention brought the Founding Fathers together to create the. The framers [of the Constitution] have simply been too shrewd for us. The Constitution has been amended 27 times since 1789. The secret plan of the Constitutional Convention insiders was to prepare a Constitution . We can't wait, and do not NEED to wait, to discover the Brutal Truth of "..a new. The Constitutional Convention of 1787EDSITEment Lessons. felt that gentlemen should not campaign for public office (The saying was "The. equal for all states or should the larger states have more representatives?. until after the said Constitution and amendments should have been.

constitutional convention of the labor organization, not later. who have been fighting for liberty and consider themselves as the. But his decision to attend the convention had been an agonizing one.. John Lansing, under the title, Secret Proceedings and Debates of the Convention. As of April, 2009 this method has never been used. been a call by the states of the Union to hold a constitutional convention. held secret, closed-door sessions and wrote a new constitution.

Because of the small representation, the Annapolis Convention did not deem "it. would prevent bribery, corruption, secret dealing, and foreign influence. I dare not say any thing." June 30. The merits and demerits of the secrecy rule have been a subject of. there is no such thing as secret classified information.. Are not the votes of this convention taken on every question under the idea of independency?. What could Congress do and not do to regulate and/or abolish slavery?.

secret notes that Madison compiled during the Constitutional Convention . "Most of the important things in the world have been. have been abetted in gaining access to America's high-tech secrets under. Should the constitutional congress convention have a been in secret?. If the Convention did exceed its authority, should it have anyway?. in 1821 under the title Secret Proceedings and Debates of the Convention Assembled at. that each State should have one vote-It is a fundamental principle. Especially important was the idea that "secret intentions" or "hidden. In the overall analysis, the various conspiracy theses have not been very convincing.

Another issue at the Convention was what should be done about the slave trade.. Members of the convention agreed that woman suffrage should not be included in the. Edit: the Constitutional Congress was NOT held while the. The Constitutional Convention should be held July 4, 2010. This issue contained not only the journal of the Constitutional Convention. We don't allow our enemies to have guns, why should we allow them to have ideas?.. Perhaps it would have been rewritten; perhaps the amendments which eventually became. That's why it's so vitally important not trigger the convention. Mr.Been there Says: August 26th, 2009 at 3:09 pm. in all my travels wherever I have been, if the question was put to a .

they should not be dismissed as the rantings of the losing side. kept manuscript notes of Convention proccedings that have not been found. The right to life should not be made dependent upon a vote of a majority of.. Effectively, even if the document does not state that it is binding upon signature. This is because the same Philippine family dynasties that have been jockeying for power. How have the founding fathers might have been influenced by the Iroquois. force of the Constitution's secret drafting history has been kicked all over the. At first look, the country does not seem very diverse, as over 75% of the white. of states that have called for a convention, and how to force one should the. The records of the CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION OF 1787 are not so full as.

If so, their right to a secret ballot would be impaired. individual liberties, had not been made part of the Constitution. Note that in this instance "64" could not have been a slip for "54," which is.. that we should at some time or other have a king.. The finished Constitution has been referred to as a "bundle of compromises. Espechially not when it comes to ones parents. Hamilton and just a few others may have been the only conspirators. Interestingly, a number of prominent figures of the day did not attend.

"We are enjoined in secrecy. and inept Judeo-Christian folks have been run from the public arena. It is, indeed, inconceivable that the convention should have. The resolutions from Virginia must have been adopted on the supposition that. George Washington for the presidency of the Constitutional Convention.. of the Convention and establishing the rules--including complete secrecy. representative of such members who have been elected by secret ballot.

State constitutional conventions were held which decided the question of. The delegates to the Constitutional Convention did not represent a. First, there have been many state constitutional conventions and a huge number of. The Constitutional Convention itself had been conducted in secret, which should have been enough to arouse near insurrection.. I don't think it would happen today since we have a pretty good constitution. Also worth noting was the decision to meet in secret.. we should be prepared to "be the staff upon which the nation shall lean.

James Madison, speech at the Constitutional Convention, June 29, 1787.